As former Prime Minister says tainted blood scandal was ‘unhealthy luck’ JASON EVANS hits again

Many individuals see Sir John Main as a ‘good’ ex-PM, maybe brief on ideology and charisma, however an honest man who did his finest.

On Monday, nonetheless, a unique facet of Sir John emerged when he gave proof to the inquiry into the contaminated blood scandal of the Nineteen Seventies and 80s, to a room stuffed with victims and their kinfolk. It was the worst therapy catastrophe within the NHS’s historical past.

It was a scandal that killed greater than 2,000 harmless folks, together with my father, Jonathan Evans.

But Main instructed the inquiry that what had occurred to those victims amounted to ‘extremely unhealthy luck’.

Understandably, his comment was greeted with gasps of shock from these within the room — myself included. For it revealed not solely surprising ignorance, but additionally breathtaking callousness.

‘Dangerous luck’?


Let me be clear: luck had nothing to do with it.

The deaths and struggling of hundreds of individuals have been brought on by negligence on the a part of the state, which then refused to take accountability, and failed to supply victims and their households the compassion they wanted and the compensation they so desperately deserved.

Later, Main supplied what he framed as an apology: ‘It wasn’t meant to be offensive . . . what I meant was . . . by sheer unhealthy luck, it was a random pattern.’

There was nothing random about it. The deaths have been the direct results of therapy given to five,000 haemophiliacs that continued to be given lengthy after the alarm had been raised over its potential risks. Remedy that, removed from bettering sufferers’ high quality of life, sentenced some to demise and left others with extreme diseases as they contracted Hepatitis C and HIV from contaminated blood merchandise.

For 3 a long time, sufferers and their households have fought desperately for solutions. However politicians, civil servants and well being officers have repeatedly tried to fob us off, fearing that act of contrition will lead to expensive compensation or harm to their careers.

Now, with the inquiry — which started in 2018 — we ultimately have the prospect to get solutions. So it’s devastating when a former Prime Minister dismisses a long time of struggling as ‘unhealthy luck’.

See also  Second group of placing paramedics broke off picket line to assist motorcyclist who fell off his bike

This saga of incompetence, lies and cover-up started within the mid-Nineteen Seventies. Till then, haemophiliacs had been handled with a blood-clotting agent known as cryoprecipitate, created from blood plasma. Like an everyday blood transfusion, it relied on voluntary donations given by means of the NHS.

A letter the former Prime Minister wrote warned that a sympathetic response to the infected blood products victims ‘could lead to an open-ended commitment of huge dimensions’ Pictured: John Major gives evidence at the Infected Blood enquiry in London

A letter the previous Prime Minister wrote warned {that a} sympathetic response to the contaminated blood merchandise victims ‘might result in an open-ended dedication of giant dimensions’ Pictured: John Main provides proof on the Contaminated Blood enquiry in London

However then got here the brand new therapy, Issue VIII, utilizing blood plasma collected from tens of hundreds of donors. If only one donation was contaminated, it contaminated the entire batch.

In Britain, blood donors have been then, and are nonetheless, not allowed to be paid, however the plasma used for Issue VIII, manufactured within the U.S. and different international locations, was typically paid for.

Plasma collectors arrange centres in poor, ‘skid-row’ places, and — as they paid for donations in money — attracted intravenous drug customers and intercourse employees, who have been extra more likely to carry viral infections. There have been even Pay-for-Plasma operations in U.S. prisons the place larger viral-risk exercise, reminiscent of unprotected intercourse and needle-sharing, have been widespread and the incidence of HIV and Hepatitis C was excessive.

As there was no screening of the blood collected from such places, there was nothing to forestall contaminated provides getting into the system.

Regardless of being warned to withdraw the merchandise from use by the UK’s most senior epidemiologist, Dr Spence Galbraith, in early 1983, Britain continued to purchase them and provides them to folks reminiscent of my father.

In mid-1983, haemophiliacs began being identified with Aids in Britain, however the inquiry has seen proof that some clinicians suppressed this data and down-played the dangers. Galbraith’s warnings have been ignored and the state stored importing massive portions of deadly Issue VIII and continued to manage it.

See also  One other 36 instances of mysterious hepatitis have been recorded, however no new deaths

At Treloar School, a faculty in Surrey for disabled kids, haemophiliac boys got the brand new clotting therapy with none warning of the excessive danger of contamination. At the moment, of the 89 boys handled at Treloar, fewer than 1 / 4 are alive.

Shockingly, there have been typically lengthy delays between a analysis of Hepatitis C or HIV and the horrible information being conveyed to sufferers, placing wives and companions in danger.

This was the case with my father. Like all younger {couples} on their marriage ceremony day, he and my mom have been blissfully glad after they married in 1984. At first, Dad’s haemophilia didn’t maintain him again. His joints acquired stiff at times from inside bleeding, however he lived an lively life, working as a carpenter.

A yr later, he was given the devastating information that he had HIV. It had been on his notes for six months by then. Fortunately my mom had not been contaminated.


My final reminiscence of him dates again to 1993. Aged 4, I used to be taken to see him as he lay dying, by which period he had been lowered to a skeleton. He died quickly afterwards.

Even earlier than his demise, my mom was sacked from her job at a bakery as a result of, because the supervisor mentioned, they couldn’t have somebody dealing with meals whose husband had Aids.

My dad and mom’ lives turned hell. They acquired threatening telephone calls and have been shunned by neighbours.

It wasn’t till a lot later that I realized the reality: that my father was the sufferer of grotesque incompetence, negligence and cover-up as medical doctors, civil servants and finally Authorities ministers tried to downplay the connection between Issue VIII and the variety of haemophiliacs being contaminated with Hepatitis C and Aids.

By 1987, John Main was Chief Secretary to the Treasury. On Monday, a letter written by him in November that yr was learn to the inquiry. It warned {that a} sympathetic response to the contaminated blood merchandise victims ‘might result in an open-ended dedication of giant dimensions’.

‘May it not give rise to courtroom motion in opposition to the Authorities due to the implication of negligence?’ he mentioned.

‘Have the legislation places of work given a view on the attainable penalties of a sympathetic response? I don’t really feel we are able to afford to supply such a response till the professionals and cons have been totally thought of.’


It appears to me that these are the cold-hearted phrases of a politician eager to save lots of the Treasury prices and win himself political capital. What about these devastated lives: kids shrivelled to baggage of bones, males like my dad dying in agony aged simply 31? Had been they only numbers on a spreadsheet?

What was extra surprising than what Sir John mentioned was what he didn’t say. Each witness is requested after giving proof: ‘Is there something you’d like so as to add?’

On this inquiry, a number of officers have taken the chance to acknowledge accountability or categorical sympathy.

However when requested, Sir John mentioned: ‘No, I feel that’s it.’ If he had made a heartfelt apology, it wouldn’t have modified something, however it will have helped us all psychologically. But he neither apologised nor expressed honest sympathy.

It was a kick within the enamel for individuals who have waited 30 years. All I can hope is that the inquiry delivers the solutions, and compensation, so lengthy delayed. However it will likely be no due to Sir John Main.

n Jason Evans is founding father of Issue 8 (, an advocacy organisation for victims of the contaminated blood scandal and their households.

Related Posts